Board Games vs Video Games — A Honest Comparison
Social skills, cognitive benefits, cost, accessibility, and fun. How traditional games and video games actually compare — with research.
The “board games vs video games” debate misses the point — both are games, and both are good for you. But they’re good in different ways, and understanding those differences helps you choose the right games for your goals.
This isn’t about declaring a winner. It’s about understanding what each type of game offers so you can be intentional about how you spend your leisure time.
Head-to-Head Comparison
| Category | Board/Card Games | Video Games |
|---|---|---|
| Social interaction | High — face-to-face or turn-based conversation | Variable — from solo to online multiplayer |
| Cognitive benefits | Planning, memory, probability, patience | Reaction time, spatial reasoning, multitasking |
| Screen time | Zero (physical) or minimal (online) | Always screen-based |
| Cost | $0–$60 for a game; free online | $0–$70 per game + hardware ($300–$2,000) |
| Accessibility | Low barrier; most ages and abilities | Varies; can require fast reflexes |
| Session length | 10–60 min typical | 10 min to hours (high addiction risk) |
| Portability | A deck of cards fits in your pocket | Requires device + often internet |
| Learning curve | Usually simple to start | Ranges from casual to extremely complex |
Cognitive Benefits: What the Research Says
Board and Card Games
Research from the University of Edinburgh (2019) found that people who played board games and card games regularly showed less cognitive decline after age 70 compared to non-players. Specifically:
- Memory — Card games require tracking what has been played, building working memory
- Strategic thinking — Planning multiple moves ahead strengthens executive function
- Probability estimation — Games like Poker, Cribbage, and Bridge build intuitive math skills
- Emotional regulation — Managing a bad hand teaches patience and resilience
Video Games
A meta-analysis published in Psychological Bulletin (2013) found that action video games improve:
- Reaction time — Fast responses to visual stimuli
- Spatial reasoning — Navigating 3D environments builds mental rotation skills
- Attention switching — Multitasking between threats and objectives
- Problem-solving — Puzzle and strategy games require creative solutions
The Overlap
Both types of games exercise the brain. The difference is which cognitive muscles get worked. Board games tend to develop “slow thinking” (deliberate analysis), while action video games develop “fast thinking” (reflexive responses).
Strategy video games (like Civilization or XCOM) actually overlap significantly with board games in the skills they develop.
Social Connection
This is where the categories differ most.
Board and Card Games
- Built for in-person or small-group interaction
- Conversation happens naturally between turns
- Reading body language is part of the game (especially in Poker or bluffing games)
- Multiplayer is the default — most card games require 2-4 players
- Intergenerational play is common (grandparents, parents, kids)
Video Games
- Online multiplayer connects people across distances
- Many popular games are solo experiences
- Voice chat exists but is often anonymous and unstructured
- Cooperative games (like co-op RPGs) can build strong bonds
- Competitive games can sometimes increase stress rather than reduce it
Online Board Games: The Middle Ground
Playing Hearts, Spades, or Chess online preserves strategic depth while adding the convenience of digital play. You get the mental workout of a card game with the accessibility of playing from anywhere.
On Rare Pike, you can play classic games with friends or strangers — no accounts, no downloads.
Cost Comparison
| Board/Card Games | Video Games | |
|---|---|---|
| Hardware | A table | $300–$2,000 (console, PC, or phone) |
| Game cost | $0 (standard deck) to $60 (premium board game) | $0 (free-to-play) to $70 |
| Recurring cost | None | Subscriptions, DLC, microtransactions |
| Online options | Free (e.g., Rare Pike) | Free-to-play models often push spending |
| Total 5-year cost | $0–$200 | $500–$5,000+ |
A deck of cards costs $3 and provides access to hundreds of games. That’s hard to beat on value.
Addiction and Screen Time
This is worth addressing honestly.
Video games are engineered for engagement. Variable reward schedules, progression systems, and social pressure mechanics are designed to keep players playing. The World Health Organization recognized “gaming disorder” in 2018.
Board and card games generally don’t have the same compulsive pull. Sessions have natural endpoints (the game ends), and there’s no infinite scroll or autoplay mechanic. That said, any activity can become unhealthy in excess.
Online board games fall somewhere in the middle — they have the finite structure of traditional games but the always-available nature of digital platforms.
When to Choose Each
| If you want to… | Choose |
|---|---|
| Bond with family | Board/card games (in person) |
| Improve reaction time | Action video games |
| Reduce stress | Card games (Hearts, Gin Rummy) |
| Play competitively | Either — both have deep competitive scenes |
| Fill 5-10 minutes | Mobile video games or quick card games (Tonk) |
| Exercise long-term strategy | Board games (Chess, Bridge) or strategy video games |
| Connect with distant friends | Online card games or co-op video games |
| Minimize screen time | Physical card/board games |
The Real Answer
Play both. The healthiest approach is variety. Use board and card games for social gatherings, cognitive maintenance, and low-screen-time relaxation. Use video games for immersive entertainment, fast-paced challenge, and connecting with online communities.
And if you want strategy games without the hardware cost: Rare Pike offers 28 free multiplayer games — classic card games and board games you can play in any browser.
Play Free — No Downloads
Board games and card games, playable in your browser. No installs, no accounts.
Browse All Games